- The
untold story Switzerland’s finest hour.
This is the untold
story of the most extraordinary rescue effort during the
Holocaust:
The rescue of 140,000
Jews in Budapest. Most people, and even historians of
this tragic period have never even heard of George Mantello,
the Jewish diplomat who conducted his rescue efforts from
the Salvadoran consulate in Geneva. They surely have no
notion of how and why of all places, Switzerland should
occupy such a prominent role. Didn’t its government return
thousands of Jewish refugees across the Swiss border into
German hands? And, wasn’t the International Red Cross,
an arm of the Swiss government, extremely unhelpful to
Jewish victims of Nazism, which it rationalized with a
litany of legalist excuses? Yet, somehow, Dr. Kranzler,
a noted Holocaust historian with nine books on rescue
and rescue attempts during this tragic era, makes a superb
case of proving the veracity of this riveting saga beyond
the shadow of a doubt;
Before the war, George
Mantello was a successful financier who had been the Honorary
Salvadoran Consul for Hungary, Romania and Czechoslovakia.
In 1942, he was appointed the First Secretary of the Salvadoran
Consulate in Geneva, where he initiated two major rescue
efforts, with the full support of his Consul General.
The first was the distribution,
gratis, of thousands of Salvador Citizenship (and protective)
papers to Jews in Nazi-occupied Europe, without distinctions
of any kind.
His second, and most
important effort was to do the impossible: halt the trains
from Hungary to Auschwitz, that carried 12,000 Jews to
the gas chambers each day.
This he accomplished
with the help of a Romanian diplomat who risked his life
to bring the reports about the atrocities in Auschwitz
and Hungary from a Jew hiding out in the Swiss compound
in Budapest, who pointed out that from May 15th. to June
15th., 1944, 500,000 Hungarian Jews had been sent to their
death. With trepidations, he awaited the final deportations
from the capital itself. Tragically, all the Jewish Organizations
in Switzerland had obtained copies of these atrocity reports
six weeks earlier. These had been sent by Rabbi Michoel
Ber Weissmandl, head of the Slovak Jewish Underground,
to which he attached the plea for the Allies to bomb the
rail lines to Auschwitz. While they all obtained Salvador
papers from Mantello, they never bothered to show him
these reports.
With the help of the
British and American Intelligence, whom he had helped
previously, and the moral leadership of several outstanding
Swiss theologians, including Karl Barth, Emil Brunner
end Paul Vogt, Mantello initiated and orchestrated a Swiss
press and Church campaign that had no counterpart anywhere.
The press resonated with over 120 newspapers and 400 bold
articles (many front-page) condemning the Nazis, Auschwitz
and Hungarian complicity. Likewise, every church, from
the urban to the smallest village church, rang with fiery
sermons on the same topic. Meanwhile, Mantello distributed
copies of the summaries of the reports to all the embassies
and foreign newspapers as well.
Within ten days, there
arose the first public outcry by Roosevelt, the Pope,
Churchill and the king of Sweden, who then dispatched
Raoul Wallenberg to Budapest. Most amazing of all, under
the moral leadership of their church leaders, thousands
of Swiss women, workers and university students, conducted
protests - demonstrations in the streets of the big cities
against their own government’s and the Red Cross’ indifference
to the fate of Hungarian Jewry. They even discarded the
much-vaunted Swiss neutrality in this battle to save the
Jews, with such headlines as, "There is No Neutrality
when Confronted by Such Crimes," etc. After a week
of such demonstrations, the Swiss government and Red Cross
capitulated to the will of its people and started to protect
Jews in Budapest, along with the now energized diplomats
of Sweden, Spain, Portugal, and the papal nuncio. Despite
Eichmann’s constant attempts to complete the Final Solution
in Hungary, the neutral diplomats now risked their lives
to protect the surviving Jews.
It is a fascinating
tale, full of irony, heroism, ingenuity, as well as treachery,
brought to light by the author’s facile pen, in this fully
documented, prize-winning work. He has also made the reader
aware of the great debt Jews (and the world) owe to the
tiny country of El Salvador, the Swiss people, and the
diplomats of the other neutral countries, without whose
full participation, no Jews in Budapest would have survived.
|